Forcing
random people to be jurors is like forcing random
people to design a
nuclear reactor or play a violin concerto. The idea is
so assinine and absurd, I hardly have words to
describe it. Today's jurors typically have no
training nor experience in jurisprudence, criminal
justice, determining
the credibility of a witness, weighing evidence and
testimony, or using
reason
and logic to judge the facts of a case. They are
the last
people I'd want judging my case if I were ever on
trial for
anything. Furthermore, jurors don't even want to
be there. They're
present only because of a scary-looking court summons
they got in the mail which threatens
to have them arrested if they fail to show up.
So essentially,
jury duty asks unqualified, untrained, uninterested
people to do
something they don't want to do. And these are
the people who
have the final say in whether another person lives or
dies or spends
the rest of his life in prison. How can this
possibly be part of
a good justice system?
Some jurors decide a person's guilt before they even
hear one word from
the defense or prosecution. They mentally label
the suspect not guilty
merely because he's "cute". Others vote guilty
because they don't like the suspect's face or race.
This is the consequence of hiring random people
to do
the job of professionals.
The Ideal Jury System
Ideally, jurors will never see the accused.
Having the
jurors see the suspect can only bias them one way or
another. Only evidence
should be used to determine guilt. Not the
suspect's face, or
clothing, or posture, or charisma, or any other
irrelevant nonsense
that defense attorneys currently use to sway
juries.
More importantly, being a juror should be a job held
only by people who've passed a
battery of tests that show they're open-minded,
rational, unbiased, and
focused on the evidence. They should demonstrate that
they are not swayed by irrelevant nonsense like an
attorney's courtroom
theatrics.
To prevent jury tampering, there should be a pool of
potential jurors.
For a given case, jurors should be selected
randomly via lottery.
The names of the selected jurors should be kept
secret, so that
no friends of the accused may bribe or intimidate
them.